Stray Shepherding — Readers’ Choice

Links for today’s readings:

Oct 14  Read: Ezekiel 14 Listen: (4:09)   Read: Philippians 1 Listen: (4:03)

Readers’ Choice posts are selected by our readers:

This week of Readers’ Choice looks back at reflections on Jesus and salvation.

Barbara, TN — Really powerful devotional…especially clarifying what a good shepherd is and isn’t and that we as the Lord’s sheep are being Shepherd by him and his perfect knowledge of us continually! Sadly we’ve had those experiences with shepherds and the best of it is that it keeps pointing out the man is not the right place to look. The Lord is my Shepherd!

This post was originally published on September 23, 2026, based on readings from Jeremiah 50:6.

Scripture Focus: Jeremiah 50:6

My people have been lost sheep;
     their shepherds have led them astray
     and caused them to roam on the mountains.
 They wandered over mountain and hill
     and forgot their own resting place.

Reflection: Stray Shepherding — Readers’ Choice

By Erin Newton

In my first year of Hebrew classes, my professor explained verb tenses and used Psalm 23 as an example. He stressed, “The Lord is shepherding me”—not simply, “is my shepherd.” His point was that the guidance of our God is continual and ongoing, not just a point-in-time fact or a past action. I have taken more classes since that day two decades ago, but this statement comes to mind often.

A note here: We must remind people that the old theory that shepherds needed to be harsh and even “break the legs of a sheep when it was unruly” is false and debunked. That’s a terrible shepherding method and a horrendous advocation for abuse. (The Park Forum has written specifically on this point in Urban Legends and Good Shepherds.)

Over the last year, I’ve experienced the “sheep without a shepherd” situation. Matthew 9:26 speaks of this: “When he saw the crowds, he had compassion on them, because they were harassed and helpless, like sheep without a shepherd.” Oddly, I was a member of a functioning church. It was a church in transition and, despite reaching out to the pastors, my concerns fell through cracks. And then again two months later. And then again two months after that.

I follow an account where a photographer’s husband is a shepherd in Switzerland. It has been fascinating to see a modern-day shepherd’s life and then reflect on modern pastoral care for the church. This Swiss shepherd spends half of the year with his flocks in the mountains. He is separated from his human community for months, being integrated and connected to his sheep and goats. He knows their personalities, their struggles, their life cycles. They move up and down the mountain depending on the season.

Change is inevitable and not necessarily bad. Jeremiah’s shepherd is moving the congregation over the hills and mountains. But it’s astray. These shepherds, who were revered among their community and blindly followed by the flock, are not as wise as they proclaim to be.

The result is a lack of rest. No peace in the community. No peace with God. No peace internally.

With all the verses about human shepherding, I’m so thankful for Psalm 23. The Lord is shepherding me. I’ve moved into a new flock with a new set of shepherds who dwell among us, knowing our lives and our hurts. But it’s still the Lord who ultimately shepherds. And he does not lead astray. He guards me; I don’t have to be his defense.

Prayer for the week:

We are taking a break from the Divine Hours Prayers this month. Each week, we will pray a prayer from Scripture or Christian history related to the week’s theme. This week’s prayer is related to our theme of Jesus and salvation:

For this reason I kneel before the Father, from whom every family in heaven and on earth derives its name. I pray that out of his glorious riches he may strengthen you with power through his Spirit in your inner being, so that Christ may dwell in your hearts through faith. And I pray that you, being rooted and established in love, may have power, together with all the Lord’s holy people, to grasp how wide and long and high and deep is the love of Christ, and to know this love that surpasses knowledge—that you may be filled to the measure of all the fullness of God. — Apostle Paul, Eph 3.14-19

Read more:  Urban Legends and Good Shepherds

Abusive leaders have used this metaphor to justify “wounding” parishioners with “tough love” because they are “good shepherds.”

Readers’ Choice is Here!

This month, we reshare your favorite Park Forum posts from this year. There’s still room for more. Tell us about one we should include.

What posts helped you heal?

https://forms.gle/Kj12Ziy4C9gQg8Xm7

Of Rings and Kings

Links for today’s readings:

Sep 25  Read: Jeremiah 52 Listen: (5:49) Read: 2 Corinthians 11 Listen: (4:46)

Links for this weekend’s readings:

Sep 26  Read: Lamentations 1 Listen: (4:44) Read: 2 Corinthians 12 Listen: (3:54)
Sep 27  Read: Lamentations 2 Listen: (4:55) Read: 2 Corinthians 13 Listen: (2:19)

Scripture Focus: Jeremiah 52.31-34

31 In the thirty-seventh year of the exile of Jehoiachin king of Judah, in the year Awel-Marduk became king of Babylon, on the twenty-fifth day of the twelfth month, he released Jehoiachin king of Judah and freed him from prison. 32 He spoke kindly to him and gave him a seat of honor higher than those of the other kings who were with him in Babylon. 33 So Jehoiachin put aside his prison clothes and for the rest of his life ate regularly at the king’s table. 34 Day by day the king of Babylon gave Jehoiachin a regular allowance as long as he lived, till the day of his death.

Reflection: Of Rings and Kings

By John Tillman

Jeremiah, the weeping prophet, ends on a note of hope.

Jehoiachin was one of Judah’s last wicked kings. Jeremiah prophesied about Jehoiachin, that even if he was a valuable signet ring on God’s hand, he would still be removed and thrown away (Jer 22.24). He also prophesied that Jehoiachin’s children would not prosper or sit on David’s throne (Jer 22.30). After three months, Jehoiachin was defeated, captured, taken into captivity, and thrown in prison. The “signet ring” was discarded (2 Kings 24.8-12).

Jehoiachin deserved his suffering. “He did evil in the eyes of the Lord.” (2 Kings 24.9) He, his father, and great-grandfather “filled Jerusalem with innocent blood.” (2 Kings 24.4) Entire nations suffer under corrupt leaders like Jehoiachin. This is true militarily and economically, but it is also true spiritually. A leader’s character affects the character of (and the consequences faced by) whatever they lead, whether it is a nation, business, team, or family.

However, there are signs of hope.

The first is from Jeremiah. After 37 years, Babylon’s king released Jehoiachin from prison. Not only that, the king treated Jehoiachin kindly, had him eat at his table at a place of honor, and provided for him for the rest of his life. This could imply that something changed in Jehoiachin’s heart and God responded.

Later, another prophet, Haggai, spoke to Jehoiachin’s grandson, Zerubbabel. Haggai reused Jeremiah’s image of the signet ring. He told Zerubbabel that God would make him a signet ring to restore order and prosperity to Jerusalem during the rebuilding of the wall and temple (Hag 2.23).

Even though Jehoiachin’s line was once cursed, God still used him to bless the world through Jesus. Matthew records Jesus’ legal lineage passing through both the discarded signet ring of Jehoiachin and the restored signet ring of Zerubbabel (Matt 1.11-12). Jehoiachin’s descendant sits on David’s throne today.

This is comforting for us when we feel discarded, lost, or cursed. Not all sufferings are punishments and sometimes we suffer due to other people’s choices. (Particularly leaders’ choices.) However, no matter if you are facing consequences of your own actions or someone else’s, if there is hope for Jehoiachin, there is hope for us.

God’s plans in every age often come down to a small group of people, or even one person, changing their hearts and choosing repentance. You can be that one. You can join or start that group. We, the church, can be like a restored “signet ring.”

Divine Hours Prayer: The Refrain for the Morning Lessons

I sought the Lord, and he answered me and delivered me out of all my terror. — Psalm 34.4

– From The Divine Hours: Prayers for Summertime by Phyllis Tickle.

Readers’ Choice is Coming!

Readers’ Choice is when we ask you to share your favorite Park Forum posts from this year. 
What posts helped you forgive?

https://forms.gle/Kj12Ziy4C9gQg8Xm7

Read more: Beyond Second Chances

Scripture is full of second chances, third, fourth, fifth, sixth, seventh chances, and beyond.

Are These Your Gods?

Links for today’s readings:

Sep 24  Read: Jeremiah 51 Listen: (10:15) Read: 2 Corinthians 10 Listen: (2:45)

Scripture Focus: Jeremiah 51.15-19

15 “He made the earth by his power; 

he founded the world by his wisdom 

and stretched out the heavens by his understanding. 

16 When he thunders, the waters in the heavens roar; 

he makes clouds rise from the ends of the earth. 

He sends lightning with the rain 

and brings out the wind from his storehouses. 

17 “Everyone is senseless and without knowledge; 

every goldsmith is shamed by his idols. 

The images he makes are a fraud; 

they have no breath in them. 

18 They are worthless, the objects of mockery; 

when their judgment comes, they will perish. 

19 He who is the Portion of Jacob is not like these, 

for he is the Maker of all things, 

including the people of his inheritance— 

the Lord Almighty is his name.

Reflection: Are These Your Gods?

By John Tillman

Jeremiah’s poem comparing God creating the world by his wisdom to idol makers creating objects of mockery by their foolishness appears in chapter 10 and here in chapter 51. Maybe Jeremiah knew we needed to hear it twice…

In chapter 10, this poem is directed at God’s people, who are adopting the practices of the nations around them. In chapter 51, the poem is directed specifically at Babylon, forecasting their downfall and the shame that their idols would bring to them.

Idolaters reject the truth of God for a lie. God’s wisdom created the world. Idolaters’ foolishness creates false gods. Instead of worshiping a glorious creator, they take created things and make from them something they call a god.

Modern folks are quick to shake our heads at ancient peoples who carved idols out of stone or wood and bowed down to them as supreme, supernatural beings. However, how different is this than our treatment of artificial intelligence? Aren’t we making it from the resources God granted—both natural resources from the earth and the resources of human intelligence? Aren’t we proclaiming it as our savior who will go before us? (Ex 32.1-4)

The tech billionaires behind Ai certainly are treating and speaking of it in salvific terms. The investors in the technology certainly expect miracles. The politicians enamored with its power certainly desire it. One prominent politician (that no one can critique without being called “deranged”) announced to the United Nations that his government would officially start calling artificial intelligence “Superior Intelligence.” This was after running a social media poll with two other names that he suggested, “Extreme Intelligence” and “Supreme Intelligence.”

No matter how amazing (or terrifying) the capabilities of artificial intelligence become in a year, a few years, or decades from now, it will never be “superior” or “supreme.” And even if some whistleblowers are correct and Ai (either independently or guided by malicious humans) destroys life as we know it, it will not be unique. We’ve created such tools before.

Even if we don’t call something “god” or bow down to it, it can still be an idol. When we rely on it, praise it, sacrifice for it, and defend it, what else could it be but an idol?

Be careful how much loyalty, praise, and resources you give to things or people, especially if those people or things are making god-like promises.

Resources: “AI, Surrender All”, The Russell Moore Show. Podcast, YouTube

Divine Hours Prayer: The Call to Prayer

Know this: The Lord himself is God; he himself has made us, and we are his; we are his people and the sheep of his pasture. — Psalm 100.2

– From The Divine Hours: Prayers for Summertime by Phyllis Tickle.

Readers’ Choice is Coming!

Readers’ Choice is when we ask you to share your favorite Park Forum posts from this year.
What posts helped you pray?

https://forms.gle/Kj12Ziy4C9gQg8Xm7

Read more: Idolatry as Parody

We become like our idols…Our hearts harden and our ears tune out and our eyes glaze over.

Stray Shepherding

Links for today’s readings:

Sep 23  Read: Jeremiah 50 Listen: (8:42) Read: 2 Corinthians 9 Listen: (2:26)

Scripture Focus: Jeremiah 50:6

My people have been lost sheep;
    their shepherds have led them astray
    and caused them to roam on the mountains.
They wandered over mountain and hill
    and forgot their own resting place.

Reflection: Stray Shepherding

By Erin Newton

In my first year of Hebrew classes, my professor explained verb tenses and used Psalm 23 as an example. He stressed, “The Lord is shepherding me”—not simply, “is my shepherd.” His point was that the guidance of our God is continual and ongoing, not just a point-in-time fact or a past action. I have taken more classes since that day two decades ago, but this statement comes to mind often.

A note here: We must remind people that the old theory that shepherds needed to be harsh and even “break the legs of a sheep when it was unruly” is false and debunked. That’s a terrible shepherding method and a horrendous advocation for abuse. (The Park Forum has written specifically on this point in Urban Legends and Good Shepherds.)

Over the last year, I’ve experienced the “sheep without a shepherd” situation. Matthew 9:26 speaks of this: “When he saw the crowds, he had compassion on them, because they were harassed and helpless, like sheep without a shepherd.” Oddly, I was a member of a functioning church. It was a church in transition and, despite reaching out to the pastors, my concerns fell through cracks. And then again two months later. And then again two months after that.

I follow an account where a photographer’s husband is a shepherd in Switzerland. It has been fascinating to see a modern-day shepherd’s life and then reflect on modern pastoral care for the church. This Swiss shepherd spends half of the year with his flocks in the mountains. He is separated from his human community for months, being integrated and connected to his sheep and goats. He knows their personalities, their struggles, their life cycles. They move up and down the mountain depending on the season.

Change is inevitable and not necessarily bad. Jeremiah’s shepherd is moving the congregation over the hills and mountains. But it’s astray. These shepherds, who were revered among their community and blindly followed by the flock, are not as wise as they proclaim to be.

The result is a lack of rest. No peace in the community. No peace with God. No peace internally.

With all the verses about human shepherding, I’m so thankful for Psalm 23. The Lord is shepherding me. I’ve moved into a new flock with a new set of shepherds who dwell among us, knowing our lives and our hurts. But it’s still the Lord who ultimately shepherds. And he does not lead astray. He guards me; I don’t have to be his defense.

Divine Hours Prayer: The Request for Presence

Show us the light of your countenance, O God, and come to us. — Psalm 67.1

– From The Divine Hours: Prayers for Summertime by Phyllis Tickle.

Readers’ Choice is Coming!

Readers’ Choice is when we ask you to share your favorite Park Forum posts from this year. 
What posts helped you understand the Bible?

https://forms.gle/Kj12Ziy4C9gQg8Xm7

Read more: Urban Legends and Good Shepherds

Abusive leaders have used this metaphor to justify “wounding” parishioners with “tough love” because they are “good shepherds.”

Don’t Become an Ammonite

Links for today’s readings:

Sep 22  Read: Jeremiah 49 Listen: (7:15) Read: 2 Corinthians 8 Listen: (3:25)

Scripture Focus: Jeremiah 49.4-6

4 Why do you boast of your valleys, 
boast of your valleys so fruitful? 
Unfaithful Daughter Ammon, 
you trust in your riches and say, 
‘Who will attack me?’ 
5 I will bring terror on you 
from all those around you,” 
declares the Lord, the Lord Almighty. 
“Every one of you will be driven away, 
and no one will gather the fugitives. 
6 “Yet afterward, I will restore the fortunes of the Ammonites,” 
declares the Lord.

Reflection: Don’t Become an Ammonite

By John Tillman

Ammonites were enemies of Israel, but also family.

Ammon was a grandson of Lot—a complex man of contradictions. Israel’s relationship with Ammon was also complex and, at times, contradictory.

Lot gradually compromised, moving farther from Abraham and Yahweh and deeper into the culture of the Canaanites. Yet, despite his obvious flaws and mistakes, Peter called Lot “righteous” and described him as “distressed” and “tormented” by Sodom’s lawlessness (2 Pet 2.7-8).

God cared for the Ammonites, too. He gave them land and drove out giants before them just as he did for Israel (Deut 2.20-21). The Ammonites had friendly relations with Israel during David’s rule but were mostly political enemies and often joined other enemies to attack Israel or Judah.

Ammon had proximity to God’s family and knew his commands and ways. Yet they chose assimilation into the surrounding culture instead of faithfulness to God’s family.

Just as Lot chose to move close to, and trust in the wealth and prosperity of, Sodom, Ammon chose to trust and boast of their wealth. Ammon chose to trust in a false god, Molek, who often demanded child sacrifice and promised destruction of enemies.

God condemned Ammon for thinking that great wealth and prosperity could protect them and for how they abused and harmed their cousin nations, Israel and Judah.

Ammon boasted of strength and would be made weak. They boasted of wealth and would be made destitute. They boasted of terrorizing their enemies and would become terrorized by everyone around them. They boasted of (and profited from) sending their relatives, Israel and Judah, into captivity and exile and would be made desperate fugitives, driven away from all that they loved.

Both individually and collectively, we must be careful about the culture we live in. Our culture boasts in strength and wealth. It boasts in terrorizing enemies and scattering fugitives and foreigners. That’s “Ammonite” culture. Are you assimilated to it? Or is it “tormenting” you as it did Lot?

Thank God that there is hope for Ammonites and those, like us, who have grown like them. Even after all the Ammonites did, God promised to restore them. Even after all we have done, God is willing to restore us.

There is room in the family of God for us, even if we’ve become a little like the Ammonites. Repent of boasting and settle among the many nations in the family of God.

Divine Hours Prayer: The Call to Prayer

Love the Lord, all you who worship him; the Lord protects the faithful, but repays to the full those who act haughtily. — Psalm 31.23

– From The Divine Hours: Prayers for Summertime by Phyllis Tickle.

Readers’ Choice is Coming!

Readers’ Choice is when we ask you to share your favorite Park Forum posts from this year.
What posts did you share with a friend?

https://forms.gle/Kj12Ziy4C9gQg8Xm7

Read more: How to Know When to Give

As the Corinthians’ generosity caused Paul to celebrate, may our generosity bring joy and refreshment to those doing good in the world.

Show Buttons
Hide Buttons
Spur a spiritual rhythm of refreshment right in your inbox
By joining this email list you are giving us permission to send you devotional emails each weekday and to communicate occasionally regarding other aspects of the ministry.
100% Privacy. We don't spam.