Balancing Justice and Mercy

Links for today’s readings:

Read: Joshua 20-21 Listen: (6:58) Read: Philippians 2 Listen: (3:45)

Scripture Focus: Joshua 20.2-6

2 “Tell the Israelites to designate the cities of refuge, as I instructed you through Moses, 3 so that anyone who kills a person accidentally and unintentionally may flee there and find protection from the avenger of blood. 4 When they flee to one of these cities, they are to stand in the entrance of the city gate and state their case before the elders of that city. Then the elders are to admit the fugitive into their city and provide a place to live among them. 5 If the avenger of blood comes in pursuit, the elders must not surrender the fugitive, because the fugitive killed their neighbor unintentionally and without malice aforethought. 6 They are to stay in that city until they have stood trial before the assembly and until the death of the high priest who is serving at that time. Then they may go back to their own home in the town from which they fled.”

Reflection: Balancing Justice and Mercy

By John Tillman

In some ways, Mosaic law is harsher than our current laws because it is more protective of human life. In some ways, Mosaic law is more merciful than our current laws because it is more protective of human life.

The “Cities of Refuge” were strategically placed to be easily reached. If someone accidentally killed someone, they could flee to these cities for protection until the death was investigated. The “Avenger of blood,” a close relative of the victim, would not be allowed to kill them before they stood trial.

When emotions are high, hot tempers can overwhelm evidence or explanations. The designation of “Cities of Refuge” was a way of stopping unintentional, accidental killings from setting off a cycle of violence and revenge. Revenge is best left to God. Justice is best served cold.

The outcome of the trial determined the penalty. The minimum penalty was confinement in the city until the death of the High Priest. Other penalties could include financial compensation or death.

Any law can be bent toward evil. Joab abused the law of the avenger of blood in order to murder a political rival during David’s reign. (2 Samuel 3.24-28) I’m sure Joab wasn’t the only one to abuse the law. Having balanced systems minimizes the opportunity for human corruption, but doesn’t eliminate it. We have a role to play in keeping the balance of justice and mercy.

God takes every human death seriously and demands justice from every community. Whether people in our communities die by neglect of our responsibilities, the malice of our actions or policies, the abuse of our power, or the violence of crime or of excessive punishment, we are responsible to provide justice.

Our power to affect our legal system is limited and slow-working. But that is not the only place to apply these lessons. It’s easy to advocate for mercy toward those who haven’t harmed us directly. It is when we have suffered that the test of our principles begins.

The desire for revenge is a personal, sinful twist of God’s desire for justice. In our personal lives, we need checks on our emotions. We need to make places of refuge for those who may harm us. We can take every harm seriously without seriously harming others.

Let us work in our personal and communal lives to be people who balance loving mercy with doing justice and doing it all in a spirit of humility. (Micah 6.8)

Divine Hours Prayer: The Request for Presence

I call with my whole heart; answer me, O Lord, that I may keep your statutes. — Psalm 119.145

– Divine Hours prayers from The Divine Hours: Prayers for Summer
by Phyllis Tickle

Read more: Cold Case Justice

Establishing justice is a Christian calling and preventing crime is as much a part of it as investigating crime.

Read more: Justice That Protects Even Criminals’ Lives

The life of the criminal matters to God…Let us ensure that we maintain justice that protects life, including the life of the criminal.

We Are All Asylum Seekers

Scripture Focus: Joshua 20.2-3
2 “Tell the Israelites to designate the cities of refuge, as I instructed you through Moses, 3 so that anyone who kills a person accidentally and unintentionally may flee there and find protection from the avenger of blood.

Student Writers Month:
This month, The Park Forum welcomes college and seminary student writers pursuing ministry careers. For more info about our yearly Student Writer program, see our website.

Reflection: We Are All Asylum Seekers

By Erin Newton

No one is immune to mistakes. Split-second reactions, emotional outbursts, or lapses in judgment are issues that plague all our lives. Harm inflicted on another person results in social, relational, or legal consequences.

In Israel, accidental murder still carried guilt, “a life for a life” (Leviticus 24.17-21). Yet, temporary asylum might be found by grasping the altar in the sanctuary or permanently relocating to a city of refuge. The offender was exiled but not completely outside of God’s presence. The contamination from murder was removed to allow restoration of the land from bloodshed. 

If the murderer could safely arrive at one of these six cities, that person would be given shelter and provisions. Protection was ensured although the bloodguilt would still exist. These cities were also the designated lands for the Levites and under their priestly care the murderer would start anew.

The only way the murderer’s guilt could be ransomed was through the death of the high priest. As representative of the nation, it was the only death considered commensurate of such great guilt. Animal sacrifices covered unintentional sins but not the death of a person. God values human life exceedingly. No ordinary lamb could be the equivalent worth of humanity.

We may think this is irrelevant to us, “non-murderers”, yet in our anger, Jesus tells us that we are as guilty as a murderer. We commiserate with Paul; although we want to do good, evil is right there with us (Romans 7.21). We cannot escape the unintentional, harmful actions we commit against one another nor can we avoid the consequences of our impulses. We are in desperate need of amnesty.

Where shall we go to grasp the altar or what place will ensure our protection? How soothing it is to know that our Great High Priest has already died and paid our ransom. How comforting it is to lay down in rest knowing God is our ever-present refuge. We no longer need to spend our lives waiting for someone else to grant us redemption. Christ has already paid the price of our bloodguilt and the ground no longer cries out to condemn us. Today we live in different political systems which means legal consequences will continue to affect us. But our refuge in Christ is eternal.

No one is immune to mistakes, but we can find ransom in the death of Jesus and safety in His care. 

Divine Hours Prayer: The Call to Prayer
I will call upon God, and the Lord will deliver me.
In the evening, in the morning, and at the noonday, I will complain and lament, and he will hear my voice.
He will bring me safely back… God, who is enthroned of old, will hear me. — Psalm 55.17

– Divine Hours prayers from The Divine Hours: Prayers for Springtime by Phyllis Tickle

Today’s Readings

Joshua 20-21 (Listen – 6:38)
Acts 1 (Listen – 3:58)

Read More about Readers’ Choice 2021
It is time to hear from you about the posts from the past eleven months (September 2020 – July 2021) that have challenged, comforted, and helped you find new meaning in the scriptures.

https://forms.gle/ozM13qvW9ouSWhJS7

Read more about Jesus, our Restorer
Even in the intensity of his own suffering, Christ healed those Peter attacked and forgave those Peter cursed at.